Customer favorites
View menu
More than just pizza, a Philly original
Papa Nick's has been an Olney favorite for over 20 years, serving generous portions made with quality ingredients — fresh dough made daily, cheesesteaks piled with 100% sirloin, and quick, friendly service that sends you home with a smile.
What people are saying
⭐ 1,000+ reviews
“Some of the best pizza I've had in a long time. Would definitely recommend to anyone wanting great food and even better service!”
“Papa Nick's did a phenomenal job with my order. The steaks were so delicious with plenty of meat and the roll was fresh and soft! And the cheese fries were delicious and tasty! I'm a customer for life now.”
“My Aunt told us about this place and we come here every time we visit!! Great cheesesteaks (beef and chicken)!!!”
- ★★★★★
“Some of the best pizza I've had in a long time. Would definitely recommend to anyone wanting great food and even better service!”
Kasey J. - ★★★★★
“Papa Nick's did a phenomenal job with my order. The steaks were so delicious with plenty of meat and the roll was fresh and soft! And the cheese fries were delicious and tasty! I'm a customer for life now.”
Meech B. - ★★★★★
“My Aunt told us about this place and we come here every time we visit!! Great cheesesteaks (beef and chicken)!!!”
Vickie D.