Customer favorites
View menu
More than just pizza, a Philly original
Papa Nick's has been an Olney favorite for over 20 years, serving generous portions made with quality ingredients: fresh dough made daily, cheesesteaks piled with 100% sirloin, and quick, friendly service that sends you home with a smile.
What people are saying
1,000+ Google reviews
“I had a chicken cheesesteak w, fried onions, mayo, ketchup, sweet peppers and some onion rings. Oh yeah with a cherry Pepsi. Along with 5 other church members lunch orders. Yes, we all did enjoy our food.”
“It’s always a good vibe in there, my food is always on point the best buffalo wings around … worth every penny you spend! I’ve never had a bad experience with my food.”
“that $3 slice is definitely 5 star 🤙🏽 pro tip: put the parmesan, crushed red pepper, garlic powder, and oregano on the slice. they have a lor stand by the door with all that on it so you can dress your pizza before you go.”
- ★★★★★
“I had a chicken cheesesteak w, fried onions, mayo, ketchup, sweet peppers and some onion rings. Oh yeah with a cherry Pepsi. Along with 5 other church members lunch orders. Yes, we all did enjoy our food.”
Venus R. - ★★★★★
“It’s always a good vibe in there, my food is always on point the best buffalo wings around … worth every penny you spend! I’ve never had a bad experience with my food.”
Tihara B. - ★★★★★
“that $3 slice is definitely 5 star 🤙🏽 pro tip: put the parmesan, crushed red pepper, garlic powder, and oregano on the slice. they have a lor stand by the door with all that on it so you can dress your pizza before you go.”
Killjoy M.